Oossa

Nurses complain about HCA’s AI scheduling tool Timpani

Nurses at HCA say its Timpani scheduling tool ignores preferences and can leave teams short on experience. HCA says nursing leaders make final decisions.

By Published by Oossa: 2 min read

JESHOOTS.COM · Unsplash

Amber Retzloff, a critical care nurse in Florida, says HCA’s Palantir-powered scheduling tool assigned her to different shifts more than half the time she requested specific 12-hour shifts over four months. She says the schedule often put her on three consecutive days and left her drained. Other HCA nurses interviewed by WIRED described similar problems, including unwanted shifts and difficulty getting schedules changed.

HCA has introduced Timpani at about 130 of its 190 locations since 2023. The software uses forecasts of patient volumes and staffing needs to build schedules. Nurses say it sometimes leaves shifts short of nurses or experienced staff, particularly on Sundays. Retzloff recalls shifts when she was the only senior nurse among four colleagues, and says she had to delay care for the sickest patients while helping newer nurses with less complex cases.

The company disputes the idea that Timpani makes staffing decisions on its own. HCA spokesperson Harlow Sumerford says nursing leaders make the final scheduling decisions and calls claims that the tool is designed to cut staffing at the expense of patient care misrepresentative. He says HCA is improving the system based on nurses’ feedback. HCA also says nurses are scheduled on about 1 percent of the days they requested off.

Nurses say that even when managers make the final call, the process has changed: appeals go to a centralized HCA team, and nurses may then have to trade shifts. Some say those trades succeed only about half the time. A former HCA data science manager, in a lawsuit alleging she was fired for raising concerns, claimed the company routinely deleted data used by Timpani, making it harder to audit the tool. HCA had not formally responded in court, according to WIRED.

Palantir’s software is also used in other health care settings, though not always for the same task. WIRED reported complaints at imaging chain Rayus Radiology about a separate tool built on Palantir Foundry, which staff said sometimes matched orders to the wrong patient or filled in incorrect details. Rayus said the report’s characterizations did not reflect its safeguards. These accounts raise questions about how well automated systems work in care settings, but they do not establish that every use of the software causes errors.

What does HCA say the tool has changed?

HCA executives have said Timpani reduces managers’ scheduling work and reliance on temporary contract nurses. In a paper published in July, innovation executive Michael Schlosser said more than 98 percent of schedules include a mix of skills and experience. Those company-reported benefits sit alongside nurses’ accounts of unwanted shifts and understaffing; the article does not provide an independent evaluation that settles the disagreement.

Why it matters

For HCA nurses, the reported scheduling problems can mean more time trying to trade shifts and less predictable time off. Nurses also say short-staffed or inexperienced teams can delay care, but HCA disputes that Timpani compromises patient care, and the article does not establish how often that happens.

Was this article useful?
Share

Read next

Oossa · Newsletter

The week in AI, explained

Every Monday: the stories worth knowing, in plain language. Free, no spam.