Oossa

AI coding tools add nearly $1 billion to health plan costs, insurers say

Blue Cross Blue Shield estimates AI-assisted hospital coding added $942 million in costs to its health plans from 2023 to 2025. The cause and impact remain disputed.

By Published by Oossa: 2 min read

Wonderlane · Unsplash

AI tools are helping hospitals code patient records and insurers review claims. Blue Cross Blue Shield Association (BCBSA) estimates that AI-assisted medical coding contributed nearly $942 million in additional costs for its health plans between 2023 and 2025. The association says much of the increase involved secondary diagnoses that moved patients into higher-paying reimbursement categories.

About $653 million of the identified billing was tied to diagnoses that did not come with a change in care, BCBSA senior vice president Luke Chalker told CNBC. The association did not attribute the full increase to AI, saying several factors can affect coding. It said 60% of hospital systems began using AI coding tools during the period.

What the higher codes may mean

A diagnosis can be legitimate even if it was not recorded before. But Brown University health economist Christopher Whaley told CNBC that some diagnoses may not affect a patient’s treatment, while still increasing a hospital’s payment. In his view, AI can make it easier to capture billing opportunities that already exist in the system.

The American Hospital Association disputed BCBSA’s analysis. It said patients are older and more medically complex, and that AI can help providers document conditions for care planning. The association argued that BCBSA’s findings lack enough context to judge effects on care quality, access or spending.

The financial consequences for patients are not directly measured in the analysis. BCBSA says higher payments can eventually contribute to higher premiums and out-of-pocket costs. Separately, benefits consultant Marsh forecasts that employer health coverage costs per employee will rise 8.2% on average in 2027, the largest increase since 2003. BCBSA’s analysis does not establish how much, if any, of that forecast is due to AI coding.

AI is being used on both sides

Hospitals can use AI to document care and submit or appeal more claims; insurers can use automated tools to review claims. BCBSA says its member companies also use AI in claims review, but that a qualified human clinician always reviews clinical denials. Healthcare advisers and coding experts told CNBC that faster documentation can help doctors spend less time on paperwork, while warning that inaccurate or unsupported codes still need to be checked.

This dispute predates AI: hospitals and insurers have long differed over which services qualify for payment. AI can let both sides review more records at greater speed, but BCBSA’s analysis does not show whether the technology is raising overall costs or improving care on balance. Whaley said higher spending could be worthwhile if it improves access or quality; he questioned spending that only helps one side of a billing dispute.

Why it matters

For people with employer health insurance, higher hospital payments can eventually feed into premiums or out-of-pocket costs, according to BCBSA. But its analysis does not prove that AI caused all the added spending or show how much patients will pay; hospitals also argue the tools can help document real medical needs.

Was this article useful?
Share

Read next

Oossa · Newsletter

The week in AI, explained

Every Monday: the stories worth knowing, in plain language. Free, no spam.